Stretching...The topic resurfaces once again!!

Stretching The Truth



Written by Allan Besselink, PT, Dip. MDT
Monday, 27 October 2008
It's finally cooling off in Austin. With cooler weather comes the start of all the marathon training programs in preparation for the Austin Marathon in February. And with cool fall weather and marathon training comes ... yes, the questions about stretching.

Stretching has become a panacea. So let's attempt to put a few things to rest with some good sports sciences evidence - though I suspect much of it may come as a surprise to many.

Let's start with a couple of interesting facts. Research on 5K runners has indicated that the fastest runners are the most inflexible. The increased passive muscle tension effectively gives the runner "free speed" because it's not requiring energy to produce it. Add to that the lack of research supporting the relationship between stretching and ---insert injury here --- [options include plantar fasciitis, achilles tendonitis, IT band syndrome, etc]. So we have to assess stretching by starting with the questions "why am I stretching in the first place?".

"Doesn't stretching makes my muscles longer?" First of all, the literature is very clear on one thing - stretching (as it is performed by most athletes, coaches, and health care practitioners) does not actually make the muscle longer. What it does do - is simply increase your tolerance to stretching - plain and simple.

It is important to discuss what stimulus needs to occur at the cellular level to evoke changes in the muscle, tendon, or surrounding collagen structures. There are two primary potential effects of stretching - a lengthening of tissue, and a neurological relaxation of muscle and the central nervous system.These are two different intents requiring two different strategies.

Would the right degree of stimulus (tension) cause these tissues to lengthen? Yes. How many times must you take the tissue to it's fully lengthened position per day? The literature would indicate 40 to 50 repetitions a DAY - minimum. How much stretching does the average athlete do? Nowhere near that much! It would require many many repetitions to the end of your range of motion for you to make true changes to the tissue (as opposed to the improved "tolerance" you might experience) and these would then have to be utilized functionally (i.e in your sport activity) to maintain them. Unfortunately, the task to get the muscle and surrounding tissues to lengthen is a rather significant one that is certainly not occuring with one or two repetitions by the athlete (or provider).

A sustained gradual stretch would be an appropriate stimulus to help to get the muscle to relax neurologically. This would be beneficial as it would simply decrease the tone of the muscle and to initiate recovery. But having said that, the timing of the stretching would be AFTER exercise, not beforehand.

"I thought that stretching needs to be done before and after my runs." As part of the warm-up, the answer would be - no. You are about to go on a run. You are about to get your central nervous system firing. If you have elevated your core temperature (breaking a sweat), then the only other thing you would want to do would be activities that help to get your central nervous system "fired-up". Gradual stretching before an activity does exactly the opposite - it gets everything to relax. This is counter-intuitive and may actually put you at risk. And yes, the increased risk factor has been documented in the sports sciences literature. After the run - a time in which you want to get the central nervous system calmed down - would be a good time for slow gradual stretching, maintaining a lengthened position for a minimum of 60 to 90 seconds per position, perhaps even longer.

"But Allan, everything I have been told by my --- insert here --- [options include coach, physical therapist, chiropractor, ART practitioner, massage therapist, orthopedist, etc] is that stretching will help me to prevent injury and is the primary way to resolve an injury should it occur."

At this point I would give a resounding "incorrect". The scientific literature has yet to confirm a relationship between these factors. As a matter of fact, the only relationship that has been established is that there is a higher risk of injury when stretching before the training activity! There has not been any supportive literature relating muscular tightness or "imbalance" to the onset of any specific injuries. So if you see a tight muscle, it's not necessarily a safe assumption that it caused your injury. Of course, this is against the beliefs of many but, once again, it is an issue of beliefs and not science.

"Allan, I know that stretching has made me ---insert here--- [more flexible, more resistant to injury, more wealthy, better able to feed the starving of the world]. How do you explain THAT?".

This is something I hear every day. You can hear the emotion creeping into the discussion. The difficulty lies in what we THINK makes a difference, and what truly effects the change physiologically. There are so many confounding variables, it is simply impossible to make the statement. We can look to the sports sciences to provide a foundation upon which to optimize our training, injury prevention, and injury recovery. Much of these issues with stretching are simply counter-intuitive physiologically or unproven in the scientific literature.

But if we removed stretching from the discussion, what would all of the ---insert here--- [practitioners, coaches, running magazines] talk about?

Now THAT could REALLY prove interesting.


The problem lies in that all stretching is put into the same lump and only 1 demographic is usually used. I completely agree with the article by the way. i work with industrial athletes as it were and they benefit from stretching because 1) they never do it and 2) anything different from their 12 hour workday will help them.